CANDIDATE QUESTIONAIRE PATRIOTS BEWARE....OF TRAITORS AMONGST YOU THE LESSER OF TWO EVILS IN VOTING
2ND AMENDMENT....BEST PRESENTATION EVER! DON'T BE NICE!!! 1ST AMENDMENT UNDER ATTACK IN GEAUGA COUNTY
AGENDA 21..... GREATEST THREAT TO RIGHTS OF PRIVATE PROPERTY, WATER, FARMING, ANIMALS GEAUGA COUNTY MOST UNWANTED OHIO CONSOLIDATION / REGIONALISM
GEAUGA PARK DISTRICT ABUSES
  » Latest Post: April 21, 2017 January 23, 2018 

TENTH AMENDMENT MOVEMENT,,,,RELYING TO HEAVILY ON IT?
Posted By: Geauga Constitutional Council 03/02/2010 @ 01:21 PM

.

.

The Partial Mistake of Relying on the 10th Amendment

I found this on some site....don't know who the author is but he really makes alot of sense.  Here it is:  

 

This is primarily going to be a work of opinion rather than fact gathering and research this evening. And that might mean that the article ends up not being all that long. But I think that this is important and should be discussed so that we don’t fall prey to making the same mistakes on a smaller scale. My focus tonight is on the recent 10th Amendment movements. I believe I recall the number being 34 of the states have taken action in some form to reaffirm state’s rights under the 10th Amendment. I support those who are making that move, but not for the same reason as many others are supporting them. So I want to discuss them, and their reasoning, and the flaw in thinking that this is the ultimate answer to the problems that we face in dealing with government today.
 

What does the 10th Amendment say? Simple enough:

 

Amendment 10 – Powers of the States and People
(Ratified 12/15/1791).

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

I think that seems pretty straight-forward, although there are many in Washington DC and throughout the states that seem to have no concept of it, or are willing to ignore the 10th Amendment in order to “serve the greater good”. Remember those that tell you this fallacy, that it is OK to ignore state’s rights in order to serve the greater good.

Because those folks will be willing to ignore any of the other rights that the Constitution points out that we have (and never forget how I worded it, the document points out that we have those rights, not that it grants them to us, an important distinction). So in light of the federal government ignoring the 10th Amendment, we have seen a large number of people supporting the idea of states reaffirming their rights under this premise.

Now here is where I am struggling with this concept. Many of you have espoused two distinct things that you support, albeit having done so in different conversations. It is clear that a majority support the idea of state’s rights and the reaffirmation of them. We have conversations and you make comments saying so. In other conversations, many of those same folks support the idea of VDLG, or more specifically scrapping the concept of government as it stands and finding a more moral or or ethical way forward. You see government as it exists today as “bad”. This may or may not put you in direct contradiction. Each of you will have to answer this for yourself once I explain what I mean.

Let me say up front that this does not apply to folks who are more in line with G.A. Rowe. GA does not contradict himself whatsoever in this concept. He supports a return to the roots of the Constitution. He does not waver from that, and I respect that he doesn’t contradict himself in this way. He believes that the government, as defined in the Constitution, will work for the people and can be controlled and used wisely. So this article is in no way aimed at him. That debate is for a different time, and wages between GA and BF regularly.

But for the rest of you, you have to answer for yourself if this contradiction exists in your thinking. This is for those who believe that the federal government is stealing when they collect most taxes. This is for those who are beginning to grasp the concept of individual liberty and our inherent right to it. For those who believe in their heart that government, through the use of immoral measures infringes on that right. For those who believe that the representatives we elect no longer work to represent us. For those who believe that government should not take from one person via force to give to another person. For those who believe that all the bad things that BF, JAC, PeterB, myself, and others are saying about the government we are seeing in Washington DC and the need for a real change, not Obama’s version…..

Why is the state government any different?

Because it is smaller? State governments still collect taxes against our will. State governments still take from you by force to give to someone else. State governments still force their will upon you. State governments still force other people’s will upon you. State governments still impose on business, ruin public education, enforce through violence, lie to our faces, and take from us the fruits of our labor. State governments are exactly the same as the federal government…. only smaller. If we agree that what government is doing is immoral, then why is it less immoral if it is done by your state government? Or even your local government?

Folks I submit to you that supporting a 10th Amendment movement for the reason that you think state government is “better”, is insane. If you want to support a 10th Amendment movement, then how about we move right past the “are reserved to the states respectively” and go right to “or to the people”. Wouldn’t that make more sense?

Now with that all being said, I promised to explain why it is, if this contradiction can exist, that I would support the 10th Amendment movement that is going on. And my answer is simple, because it is a step in the right direction. The problem with the federal government is the centralization of power. All the power of government is centered in Washington DC, in the hands of 545 people. And those 545 people who have ALL the power, are not interested in helping us. They don’t care if the sick have health care. They don’t care if the economy improves. They don’t care if Bob the Builder loses his house. They care about power, and that is why for 100 years they have worked to consolidate and centralize it in Washington DC, in federal government.

Decentralization is the first step in getting the power back into the hands of the people, because in the end the people are the ONLY ones who care about their individual liberty. The state government is smaller. And smaller means more able to be opposed by the people. You have heard from some of us that the only hope for change is at the local level. Because that is the only place where you can effect real change; at home, where the issues matter to a high percentage of voters. If we can decentralize the federal government and get a majority of the power in the hands of the states, we have accomplished step one.

 If we have done that we can begin to decentralize the power of the state (or not, it is up to the people of that state) in order to get the majority of the power into the hands of local governments. And local governments are where we have the ability to organize and really affect change to how things work. If you know taxing the crap out of the wealthy in your town means that they will pick up and move to the nearest town that doesn’t tax the crap out of them, you might think a lot harder about stealing from Peter to pay Paul. More importantly, at the local level you can organize and find ways to fund what needs funding without the need to collect taxes against the will of people. And don’t tell me it can’t work, because tribes of people all over the world have governments that look nothing like the government as we view it today, that serve the public good without doing the harm that our version of government does.

So now I will leave it to all of you to tell me where I am wrong, what I am missing. I am sure that I am missing something because I didn’t research and I took a very general approach to this subject.

Unknown Author

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 

.

Excerpt from above:

"And local governments are where we have the ability to organize and really affect change to how things work."~~~~~~~~

"the only hope for change is at the local level. Because that is the only place where you can effect real change"~~~~~~~~~

 

To put it briefly, for over 2 years now, way before the 9-12 Tea Party groups formed, I have been telling people that the immediate solution to our problems with the runaway tyranical government is; The authority of the county Sheriff and 10th Amendment rights of the people.

In my opinion, the Tea Party people have been duped and misled by that phoney clown Glen Beck 

 and most of them are not wise enough to see it. They are all trying to control and fight at the federal level, wasting precious time doing it, while alot of (not all) their local politicians and Sheriffs, who are doing the same thing to them that the feds are, have pretty much been ignored. 

The Tea Baggers have been wasting their money and time preaching to the choir, taking bus load after bus load of people to Washington for a show of force and to let Washington know they are being watched.

Oooooo, I'm sure they are all afraid! 

The fact is, nothing much has changed, we are still headed in the same direction. They hold rallies with many speakers and afterward not much is done to organize and educate their local communities and bond with the Sheriff, if he is a good one.  They are just preaching to the choir.

Obama and his administration are ignoring you Tea Baggers and doing end plays around you! They laugh at you and think you are fools!! The question is....are you going to continue to prove them right?

The Tea Baggers should be spending their time and money on sending busloads of people to their local politicians and raising alot of hell repeatedly at the local level!

To be fair, a small minority of Tea Baggers are actually doing something.  

You don't have to be real smart to figure out that if the states have far more powers than the feds, and the states gave the feds their very limited power, not the other way around, and the county Sheriff has more authority than the President, than any federal agent from any department, than the Governor, than any Judge.........

then wouldn't it make perfect sense to concentrate your money and efforts where the real power is..... on your county Sheriff and local politicians, making sure you have good ones?

Does this make sense to any of you?!

 



Mail this post to a friend
Fields marked with a (*) are required
*Your Name:
*Friend's Email:
Short Message:
 


Latest Headlines
04/21 - ARE THEY IMMIGRANTS OR REFUGEES??
04/21 - TO PRESIDENT TRUMP AND CONGRESS
04/19 - CONGRESSMAN DAVID JOYCE - IS HE REALLY CONSERVATIVE?
04/19 - MISSOURI HAS NO ILLEGALS
04/19 - CONGRESSMAN DAVID JOYCE...SELLOUT
04/16 - HAPPY EASTER TO THE WHOLE WORLD
03/30 - MARY BRIGID MATHENEY / CHARDON PROSECUTOR JAMES GILLETTE--- UNHOLY ALLIANCE??
03/17 - CHARDON POLICE OFFICER / THIEF
03/16 - CHARDON PROSECUTOR JAMES GILLETE..... WORTHLESS?
02/17 - GEAUGA COUNTY..... "SANCTUARY COUNTY"?
02/07 - GEAUGA COUNTY CORRUPTION
01/28 - BRIDEY MATHENEY HYPOCRITE
01/24 - SEND YOUR COMMENTS
01/20 - GEAUGA PROSECUTOR MARY (BRIDEY) MATHENEY DUI ON FOX 8 NEWS
01/18 - BRIDEY MATHENEY (GEAUGA PROSECUTOR) D.U.I.
01/10 - GEAUGA PROSECUTOR BRIDEY MATHENEY CHARGED WITH D.U.I. IN BAINBRIDGE
12/20 - THE COMMUNIST TAKEOVER OF AMERICA - 45 DECLARED GOALS
12/18 - DONALD TRUMP AND POLITICAL CORRECTNESS - HE MAKES ALOT OF SENSE!
12/18 - FREEDOM OF SPEECH BEING SUPPRESSED BY "POLITICAL CORRECTNESS"
12/16 - OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY MORITZ COLLEGE OF LAW STUDENT THREATENED FOR PRO LIFE BELIEFS
12/13 - VACCINATION HORRORS
12/13 - FLU SHOTS FORCED.... DON'T TOLERATE THIS!!
07/04 - INDEPENDENCE DAY? -- HAPPY 4TH OF JULY? -- YA RIGHT!
04/16 - GEAUGA PARKS EXTREMIST GROUP MEMBER ATTACKS WOMAN
03/01 - DO YOU HAVE PEACE?
11/14 - IT'S NOT ABOUT THE NAIL!
11/07 - GEAUGA PARKS GREENIE CULTISTS PROMOTE THEIR MISSION WITH LIES
11/07 - GEAUGA PARKS RADICALS USE THE DISABLED AND LIES TO SMEAR PARK BOARD
11/06 - GEAUGA DEMOCRATS HAVE TALENT AND HEART BUT POOR LEADERSHIP
11/01 - AUBURN TOWNSHIP BALONEY
10/13 - GEAUGA COMMISSIONER BLAKE REAR.... HYPOCRISY THEN NAUSEA
09/14 - GEAUGA COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
09/11 - ENVIRONMENTAL RADICALS.... SCARE TACTICS, HIDDEN AGENDA, HYPOCRISY
09/11 - PROTECT, CONSERVE, PRESERVE.... OR NATURE NAZIS
09/10 - SOCIALISM.... DO YOU KNOW WHAT IT IS?
09/08 - GEAUGA PARK BOARD BRIAN JOHNSTON.... ANOTHER GREAT ADDITION!
08/29 - SHERIFF RICHARD MACK ASKS FOR YOUR HELP
08/29 - GEAUGA COUNTY PROBATE JUDGE GRENDELL BEING INTIMIDATED BY PREVIOUS PARK BOARD MEMBERS
08/24 - PAT MULA (EX CHESTER TWP TRUSTEE) IS A FLAMING HYPOCRITE
08/24 - PHOENIX POLICE SERGEANT SHOOTS AND KILLS MENTALLY ILL WOMAN
08/23 - ALEX JONES.... POLICE BRUTALITY IN AMERICA 2014
08/23 - LOS ANGELES POLICE IGNORE MANS PLEAS FOR HELP.... HE DIES IN CUSTODY
08/23 - OKLAHOMA CITY COP ACCUSED OF SERIAL SEX CRIMES WHILE ON DUTY
08/23 - NEW YORK POLICE CHOKE HOLD DEATH OF ERIC GARNER
08/15 - OBAMA CALLED "NIGGER" BY POLICE COMMISSIONER
08/15 - GUN RIGHTS.... REASONS WHY AMERICANS SHOULD CONTINUE TO PROTECT THEM
08/10 - CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY PATROLMAN PUNCHES WOMAN REPEATEDLY IN FACE
05/16 - OBAMA CALLED "NIGGER" BY POLICE COMMISSIONER
05/07 - MARY SAMIDE VOTED OUT TWICE
05/05 - CHESTER TOWNSHIP 2014 POLICE RENEWAL LEVY
04/20 - DOES DAVID JOYCE DESERVE YOUR VOTE?
04/20 - HAPPY EASTER TO THE WHOLE WORLD
04/16 - CONGRESSMAN DAVID JOYCE vs FREE SPEECH
04/14 - THE TWO FACES OF MARY SAMIDE
04/14 - GEAUGA COUNTY.... TIME FOR GENUINE LEADERSHIP
04/06 - GEAUGA DEFENDER OF CONSTITUTION
04/05 - BEWARE OF WHO YOU TRUST
03/25 - GEAUGA COUNTY COMMISSIONER PRIMARY
09/15 - GEAUGA HABITAT FOR HUMANITY.... WHOAAA, NOT SO FAST!
08/12 - GEAUGA COMMISSIONER JEMISON SHUTS DOWN MEETING WHEN CHIEF DEPUTY PUT ON SPOT
08/12 - GEAUGA HEROIN PROBLEM SHOWING SOME OF OUR "POLITICIANS" TRUE COLORS
08/11 - SHERIFF McCLELLAND NEVER HAD PLAN AND JUDGE STUPICA DOES TURNAROUND
08/01 - CHESTER TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE KEN RADTKE
07/31 - GEAUGA COMMISSIONER RALPH SPIDALIERI ADDRESSES HEROIN PROBLEM
07/30 - ANTONIO WEST, 13 MONTH OLD BABY SHOT IN FACE AND KILLED BY 2 BLACK TEENS
07/30 - TRAYVON MARTIN PROTESTERS
07/29 - GEAUGA COUNTY.... WHERE HAVE ALL THE "REAL" LEADERS GONE?
07/29 - WHERE HAVE ALL THE REAL LEADERS GONE?
07/26 - OBAMA'S SEXUAL AGENDA
07/23 - GEAUGA COUNTY, HEROIN AND GOVERNMENT SUBSIDISED HOUSING
07/19 - GEAUGA COUNTY "GOOD OLD BOYS CLUB" AND THE VOTERS
07/18 - TRAYVON MARTIN SHOOTING ACCORDING TO TED NUGENT
07/04 - FREEDOM ISN'T FREE!!!!!
06/04 - NEW YORK: 26 PEOPLE SHOT IN 22 SEPERATE SHOOTING INCIDENTS
04/07 - GEAUGA COUNTY COMMISSIONER MARY SAMIDE CAUGHT LYING AGAIN
04/07 - GEAUGA COUNTY PROSECUTOR JIM FLAIZ TAKES A STAND ON RETIRE/REHIRE
04/07 - MODERATES ARE "MILKTOAST"......... AND WORSE
04/03 - SHERIFFS ALL OVER COUNTRY SAY "NO" TO OBAMA GUN CONTROL.... UPDATE
04/01 - FEDERAL RESERVE.... THE MAIN CAUSE OF AMERICAS PROBLEMS
03/29 - HAPPY EASTER TO THE WHOLE WORLD
03/27 - SOCIAL SECURITY IS A PONZI SCHEME
03/26 - T. J. LANE CASE.............. TRAGEDY AND HUMILIATION
03/04 - GEAUGA COMMISSIONERS JEMISON AND SAMIDE STAGNATE THE COUNTY
02/24 - GEAUGA COUNTY DOUBLE DIPPING OUT OF CONTROL
02/10 - GEAUGA COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING
02/08 - WHITE HOUSE: DRONE STRIKES ARE LEGAL, ETHICAL AND WISE
02/06 - SHERIFFS ALL OVER COUNTRY SAY "NO" TO OBAMA GUN CONTROL
02/03 - OREGON SHERIFF TIM MUELLER: "UNCONSTITUTIONAL GUN CONTROL LAWS WON'T BE ENFORCED"
01/23 - OBAMA GUN CONTROL
01/23 - JOE BIDEN: FOOL AND IDIOT
01/08 - EVER LEARNING / NEVER ABLE
09/05 - GEAUGA PARK DISTRICT ROYAL FLUSH
08/31 - CANDIDATE QUESTIONAIRE
07/16 - GEAUGA COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY WRECKING CREW
07/16 - AGENDA 21 FOR DUMMIES
07/16 - GEAUGA COUNTY LOW INCOME/ SECTION 8/ SUBSIDISED HOUSING CRISIS
07/07 - 2ND AMENDMENT.... THE TEETH OF THE CONSTITUTION
07/04 - HAPPY INDEPENDENCE DAY.... REALLY?
06/27 - FARMAGEDDON........ GOVERNMENT HARASSMENT OF SMALL INDEPENDENT FARMERS AND CO-OPS
06/25 - NEVADA SHERIFF SWAT TEAM STOPS FEDERAL GOVERNMENT